Losing your virginity…it’s got to happen at some point right? Whether you are itching to lose it as a teen, or waiting until marriage (or somewhere in between) you are more than likely going to lose it eventually.
But losing it doesn’t always work out the way we planned. So 41 college women shared the story of when they lost their virginity to give a more accurate portrayal than say, The Notebook.
Honestly, I just wanted to get it over with and see what all the fuss was about. My first time was with my boyfriend of three months and it was average I would say. It wasn't really special, the lights were on, and we were in the basement, on his family’s guest bed. It was somewhat uncomfortable both physically and emotionally, and it wasn't the best feeling in the world, but it was a good experience in that he was kind and conscious of me the entire time, which wasn't very long luckily. I guess it was a positive experience, but I regret not waiting for someone I really loved and wanted to share that experience with. I wish I had waited, but its not something you can take back... to me it just happened, it wasn't remarkable in any way.
-Annie, Bentley University Class of 2018
My first time was the summer going into senior year of high school. My boyfriend and I sneaked into this golf course, and we were both really nervous. I was nervous because I heard such awful first-time stories from everyone I knew. I was bracing myself for the pain and blood, but it ended up feeling amazing! It was definitely awkward since it was both of our first times, but I enjoyed it a lot, and it definitely lasted a lot longer than I thought it would. When it was over and we were dressed, I looked at him and asked, "You're not going to become a douchebag right?" It's been four years, and we're still together, and no, he's not a douchebag!
-Nicole, University of Florida Class of 2017
Well, I remember it clearly because it happened hours before I graduated high school… This guy and I had been hooking up since August 2014 and finally decided to have sex. And I didn't expect too much so I wasn't too disappointed. It happened in his bed, he invited me over cause his mom wasn't home (surprise). I regretted it afterwards though because he was a dick to me but silly me, when back for a second time, a few months later, it was definitely 100% better, felt better, I knew what I was doing. But, a few months after that he tells me that the condom broke...both times. Thank god I was on the pill. Moral of the story, don't be that guy, and always check before you leave.
-Faye, York College of Pennsylvania Class of 2019
My first time having sex wasn't bad at all. I was with my first boyfriend at the time. We had talked things over and eventually I told him I was ready. We didn't plan a time and day to actually have sex. I would say it happened as naturally as it could have. It didn't hurt like I had been told it might. I am no longer with him but I don't regret that step I took with him.
-Mariah, Salem State University Class of 2019
It was prom night, junior year of high school. Felt like a success then, feels a success now to be honest.
-Emily, Hamilton Collage Class of 2019
It was romantic. It was with my boyfriend. It was the night of my high school graduation. It was a very positive first experience — he made me feel comfortable and loved. Afterwards, I was surprised that that was it! I thought I'd see fireworks, feel really emotional, or feel like a different person after, but I felt exactly the same.
-Shannon, Bryant University Class of 2017
The first time I had sex was when I was a sophomore in high school, and it "went down" on my bonus-room couch with my "serious" significant other of a few months. It wasn't really something either of us thought would happen that day, but it "just happened" in the moment. After, we high-fived and went to Wendy's for dinner... How romantic, right?
-Amy, Bucknell College Class of 2018
My first time was with my boyfriend in my junior year of high school. It was in his white pick-up truck, parked in a field, and I was wearing a baggy t-shirt and athletic shorts. So basically it wasn't picturesque or magical and I didn't hear wedding bells or anything, but I'm so happy I lost it to someone I really loved. What was special was that we lost our virginities together. There was no pressure for sex to be anything out of this world, but we did wait for both of us to be ready for it. (I'm also still with the guy).
-Alex, Case Western Reserve University Class of 2017
I was 18 and he was 21. I always thought I would be the girl who loses it with a guy she's been serious with for months. Instead I lost it after knowing this guy for three weeks. It's true I rushed losing my virginity and I didn't know much about him but in spite of the circumstances, he and I were together in some sense for about 8 months. While there were many times he didn't appreciate me as much as I deserved, he taught me a lot and I'm happy he didn't just toss me to the side right after I give him a precious gift. I fell hard for my first and so much happened while we were "together" but like I said he taught me a lot and I just try to look back on the good times we spent together.
-Rachel, Temple University Class of 2018
The first time I had sex, I was 16 and it was with my boyfriend who I would go on to date for three years. Honestly, I don't really remember much about it today other than it was really awkward. We didn't even really do any other sexual activities before we jumped straight into the sex because neither of us really knew what we were doing. I wish we had worked our way into it. I think it could have been a lot better...and maybe a little more memorable.
-Jamie, Oklahoma State University Class of 2016
Horrible. I was 18 and I had been dating my boyfriend for almost 8 months. He was a virgin too but he had been dropping hints for a while that he wanted us to finally have sex. I really didn't want to (and I told him this many times) but I was under the notion that no one went to college a virgin, and I sure as hell didn't want to be that one girl. Let me clarify I was not in love with my boyfriend, but he was in love with me, and his constant nagging about sex made me feel guilty that I wasn't giving him what he wanted. So one day when I was dog sitting my best friend’s dog, I called him over and said OK. It hurt, and since neither of us knew what we were doing it was awkward and uncomfortable. I wish I hadn't done it, because then all he wanted to do was sex and I wanted no part in that so it started to drive us apart. I am happy I got it over with, but I am definitely waiting until I have strong feelings for someone before I have sex again.
-Margaret, Miami University Ohio Class of 2019
It was unplanned and not at all what I was expecting. It was with someone I had just met who didn't think I was a virgin, and he had a girlfriend at the time. One thing led to another and I kind of just let it happen. We were safe, but it wasn't anything fun like the way they make it seem on TV or anywhere else. I tried to date him after but never developed any romantic feelings for him and we never did it again. I kind of wish I had waited for someone special, but I know at the time I was insecure about just getting it over with because it seemed like "everyone was doing it."
-Erica, University of Connecticut Class of 2017
I was 18 and at my lake house for a long weekend my freshman year of college. It was just a few close friends and I watching videos and drinking. It was really fun. I found myself in my childhood lake house bedroom with my best friend, who I've been in love with for a few years. It was nice; he made sure I was comfortable because he knew I was new to the whole thing.
-Amanda, Georgia College & State University Class of 2017
It was with my first real boyfriend and we didn't wait very long. I was 16 (so in other words young and naive). He seemed so nice and I trusted him right away not to hurt me. We had sex a little after a month of dating, and it wasn't anything special. I was scared, we were on his couch, and it lasted probably 5 minutes. I wasn't ready. After we had sex, everything changed and he thought he could control me. He was a very horrible person who hurt me a lot and I thought I was in love with him, so I stayed for a while. From my experience, I now know that it's always better to wait no matter how curious you are. If you don't know the person well enough and you’re not in love with them, then wait before you jump into something you aren't ready for!
-Marissa, Siena College Class of 2018
I was really young, 16 years old, I think. It happened with my boyfriend at the time, but it wasn't his first time. He was very cautious with me and very comforting and supportive. He asked me several times if I actually wanted to go through with it. I remember, it was on a Sunday night before school and I had slept over at his parents house without them knowing! It was really risky and they weren't too pleased with us the next morning. It hurt a lot at first, but after a minute or so it was completely fine! I remember thinking, "That's it? That's what everyone is going crazy about?" I didn't think it felt bad or good – it just happened. Afterwards, I was excited to tell my best friend I'd finally done it. It wasn't a big deal to her because she, along with most of the other girls in my grade, had already experienced it. It was kind of my own little parade. I was so pleased with myself.
-Catherine, University of Nebraska-Lincoln Class of 2018
I thought I was ready to have sex. I was 15 and my boyfriend at the time was 17. He didn't pressure me and we had a mature (and kind of awkward!) conversation about having sex because we were both virgins. On our six-month anniversary, he treated me to dinner and we drove around town where he eventually parked in an elementary school parking lot near my house. Things started to get heated from there and I remember straddling him because that was pretty much the only position that was going to work in the car. It hurt, but he was super understanding during and after the whole ordeal. The next day at school I remember feeling like everyone just knew that I wasn't a virgin anymore. We are no longer together, but I did love him at the time. I just wish that he didn't have something of mine that I can never get back.
-Logan, Virginia Commonwealth University Class of 2019
My first time was horrible. I was on my period and neither of us knew what to do, as it was our first time. He saw the blood about 10 minutes in and, needless to say, that was the end of that session.
-Natalie, University of Texas at Austin Class of 2019
It was with my boyfriend two weeks into our relationship. We had gotten into a small car accident on the way to his place, a two-hour drive from my campus. We had to have his parents come pick us up and waited over an hour. He had to call out of work and it was just bad. He felt bad for ruining our first weekend together and we were planning on doing it anyway so I just kind of did it to make the night better for him. I don't really regret it, I am happy it was with him. It kind of made me more self-conscious because I wanted to be better for him. We ended up having sex about 7 times that weekend in total because we both fell in love with the idea of it. It made us more connected and the relationship just ended after 2 years. I am happy my first time was with him but I wish it were under better circumstances.
-Marissa, Framingham State University Class of 2017
I was 18 years old and had just started dating my best friend of 4 years who I’d always had feelings for. My first time was very memorable and perfect for me. We listened to Bon Iver and were both very, very careful about everything. Almost 2 1/2 years later, I'm still with him so I guess I wasn't too bad at it!
-Stephanie, Christopher Newport University Class of 2017
I was 16 and I met a boy through a friend at a hockey rink. He got my number and the next week he came over when my parents weren't home. Although sex wasn't necessarily planned on my part, it definitely was on his. As soon as he walked in the door he brought me upstairs and it just kind of happened. It was awkward and he did all the work while I was just lying there. After it was over at first I felt happy because I was "more experienced" than my group of friends at the time. But within a few minutes I was calling my friend crying to her on the phone because I felt like I had made a big mistake with someone I barely knew, and because he didn't use a condom. Because he was older and because I hadn't had sex before, I felt very uncomfortable asking for him to use one. Overall I would say it was a pretty negative experience and I was very uninterested in spending time with boys for months after that. I never did spend time with him again after that night, but he did text me to hangout again, which I ignored.
-Brittany, Wilfrid Laurier University Class of 2017
My first time having sex was very uncomfortable and painful. I didn't expect it to hurt that bad and the whole time I was afraid my mom would walk in.
-Brihanna, Temple University Class of 2017
I made the mistake of having sex at the young age of 15, simply because I wanted to get it over with. Unlike most girls' ideas of having the "perfect first time," I thought that if I got it out of the way I could avoid the awkwardness and novelty of it by the time the right guy came around. The guy I did it with wasn't important to me and now I sort of wish I had given it a little more thought and picked someone special.
-Gloria, Virginia Commonwealth University Class of 2018
My first time was sort of impersonal. It was with my boyfriend. We were both 15, and it was Halloween. We didn't really know what to expect. But afterwards I felt strangely relieved that it was over and done with. Like almost everyone's first time, it wasn't exactly comfortable. Noises happened that we weren't expecting, but we learned to laugh it off and became much closer as a couple. I loved that boy so much, and I wouldn't have wanted to lose it to anyone else. Looking back, part of me wishes that we had waited until we were older. But yeah, that was my introduction to the wonderful world of sex.
-Chapin, Hofstra University Class of 2019
It was a few weeks before my 17th birthday, and I had been with my boyfriend for about a year and a half. He was a year older, but also a virgin. I was the second one in my friend group to have sex. We had been talking about it for a long time, and had decided to put it off for most of our relationship. A few weeks before, it came up again. My reasoning was that if I didn't lose my virginity to him, who knows who I would lose it to. I loved him, and we had been each other’s first everything. I don’t know if I thought we would be together forever, but I certainly couldn’t imagine a life without him. We talked about it and decided to do it, without setting a date. So January 4th, he took me on a romantic date to the Cheesecake Factory, and on the ride back to my house, I told him I wanted to do it. He stopped at a Rite Aid to buy condoms while I ran into a nearby restaurant to say hi to some friends eating there. We went home, went down to my basement, and started to have sex. It hurt so badly that I cried. He wasn’t able to enter me fully – in fact it wasn’t even close. I spent the next half hour crying, him holding me, saying we never had to try it again and that he was so sorry. I had already felt that I had let the adults in my life down by deciding to do it, and now I felt even worse because I had let him down. We didn’t try again for a long time, and it didn’t work then either. Not until five months later did we finally successfully have sex, and it was the most gentle and special thing I have ever experienced. I’m not disappointed that I lost my virginity as a process rather than in one act, and I’m not disappointed that it was with this boy.
-Caitie, University of Notre Dame Class of 2018
It was sophomore year and with a friend I'd met freshman year. We knew when it was happening it'd be a one-time, in-the-moment kind of thing because it was after a party and we just kind of went back to his dorm room. I was just so nervous; I couldn't shut up! I must have told him a million and one times it was my first time and I didn't know what I was doing but that I still wanted to do it and I was glad it was him because he's such a nice guy and on and on. I am honestly surprised he wasn't like ‘yeah maybe let's not do this’. So pretty much, my poor friend will never be able to forget that he took my virginity. But also, double embarrassing for me was that I was rather loud and one of his suitemates, who I am also good friends with, was in his room next door and heard the whole thing. So that's cool! However through every dumb thing I said like "I'm glad it was you" or "Was I any good at it?" (Yes, I actually asked that because I am that lame) I'll still always think of that night as a good experience. I was just able to have fun with him and laugh, and tell him exactly what I wanted. It also helped a lot that he was very considerate and never did anything without asking first if I wanted to (because he'd obviously done it before and wasn't freaking the hell out for no reason like me). But anyway, I look back on it and I smile or I laugh because of how much of a moron I was and how understanding he was and that's what makes it a good first time, I think, rather than what it actually felt like.
-Molly, NYU Class of 2018
Honestly, it was kind of a wreck. It was in the woods outside a frat party on a rainy September night during my first semester in college. It was rushed because I felt left out that I was the one of the only girls in my friend group who was still a virgin. So when this really cute football player started talking to me and kissing me and asking me if I wanted to go into the woods with him, I said yes. I regretted it for a while because he turned out to be not a good person. But I don't regret it now because it shows how much I've grown into my sexuality and matured. Since then, I've learned so much about myself and what sex means to me.
-Shannon, Stony Brook University Class of 2018
Underwhelming. It lasted like maybe 10 seconds, and hurt a lot and was overall pretty weird. I had been dating my boyfriend for a month in my freshman year of college so I guess I felt obligated to have sex with him, so we did.
-Lauren, University of Wyoming Class of 2016
I had sex in a car because I was too impatient to wait for the opportunity to use a bed (or anywhere else in a house). It was with this guy I hardly knew; we had been “shipped” by our mutual friend. I just wanted to experience it before I started college. It was supposed to be a summer fling, but it was so awkward that we never talked again after that. I regret it, not because I miss my virginity or because I didn't experience a "special" first-time, I regret it because it just wasn't enjoyable: it was extremely hot in the car, we were both paranoid the whole time, the car was so small that we could barely move, and because we knew nothing about each other we were completely silent before and after. The only good thing that came out of it was that it made the next time I had sex that much better!
-Sarah, Bentley University Class of 2019
I actually got walked in on my first time having sex. My boyfriend at the time shared a room with his little brother (who was really only a year or two younger than me), and his brother came upstairs while we were in the middle of it. Instead of jumping up to block the door — as I assumed he would — my boyfriend rolled off of me and hid beside the bed. I pulled the sheet up over my head at the very last second. His brother walked in and quickly walked back out. On the plus side, he learned to knock after that.
-Rebecca, University of Maryland Class of 2017
It was definitely the right time. Everything felt great for both of us; it didn't hurt me at all! We went for so long, and then freaked out because the condom broke!! I cried as he assured me that there was no chance of me being pregnant because he hadn't finished. I was so scared and he felt so bad because he felt like he had ruined my first time, but in reality I really enjoyed it up until that point.
-Kali, Cleveland State University Class of 2019
My boyfriend and I had been together for six months. I was 19 and he was 21. We made this big deal; we got a hotel in a beautiful city, had a nice dinner at a fancy restaurant, and it was Valentine's Day. I wanted it to be this wonderful experience, but it was just.... eh. We had been used to doing other things for a while, so it didn't feel like a big deal.
-Laura, Clemson University Class of 2017
My ex thought using an extra lubed condom would make it easier but it actually made it worst, like it was so slippery it kept slipping out and by the time he finally got it in I told him I was over it and walked away.
-Kaitlyn, Bryant University Class of 2016
I was 16 and it was on Valentine's Day. It was in my parents’ basement and we didn't do any foreplay. I didn't even take off my shirt. I thought I wanted it, but it hurt because I wasn't ready, I wasn't wet. It wasn't fun. For a long time, I thought that's just what sex was, because no one took the time to make sure I was comfortable or enjoying myself. It hurt every time, but I told myself I loved my boyfriend and it made him happy and that's what sex was all about. When we broke up, I convinced myself that I loved him for a really long time. When I had sex the next time with a guy I had a genuine connection with, and he actually wanted to go down on me, I was shocked. I've still never had an orgasm, but I learned that sex can be fun, that it shouldn't hurt, and that I'm more than just a body.
-Sarah, Hofstra University Class of 2019
We'd even had a huge argument the night before it happened. Basically, my first time was "make-up" sex. Emotionally, not the best decision I've ever made. It was horrible. I had said yes to him verbally, but my body was screaming no. I was in extreme pain and was crying because of it. I didn't know what to do. I wanted this boy to love me. I wanted everything to be okay between us. I wanted this to fix everything. Instead, it ruined everything. When I asked him to stop he did, and that was that. For the remainder of our relationship I was too scared to try again because of how much it hurt. But to me, I had lost my virginity. A little over a month later, some conversation came up about it between him and I where he told me "it didn't count" as sex. I was in shock. Didn't count? What does that even mean? Our whole relationship, I hadn't been one to verbalize my opinions or stand up for myself out of fear that I would lose him, but this was the breaking point. I had just given myself to this boy, and been told I wasn't good enough. I was an emotional wreck. I told him, "Just because you didn't finish, doesn't mean it didn't count." That was the first and last time I ever stood up to him. Things ended a week after that and we went without talking to each other that entire time. He made no effort to apologize and while I was willing to try and work it out (stupidly), he didn't even say "hi" to me while we were at a mutual friend's party and dumped me a day later.
-Nicole, University of Connecticut Class of 2017
Magical. Perfect. Chocolate-y. Romantic. Just kidding. It was a Friday afternoon in high school while his parents were both at work. It was how any first time should be - confusing, nerve-wracking and slightly uncomfortable...but cute and somehow unforgettable.
-Jen, University of Illinois Class of 2017
It was in his room; very comfy sheets I might add, a glow of a TV fake fire... I know how romantic! With music in the background, I lost my virginity to the song 'Sex' by the 1975…how ironic!
-Saskia, University of Virginia Class of 2019
It was my 10-month anniversary with my high school boyfriend and I remember the whole thing being somewhat planned out. He made me go get him a glass of water and he locked me out of my room. After standing there for five minutes impatient, he opened the door and I found flowers on the floor, one lit candle, a banner that said "Happy Anniversary" (looked like it was drawn by a five year old) and the song “She Will Be Loved” by Maroon 5 played in the background. I wish I could say I am making this up but he gave me the romantic comedy scenario I always wanted. (Though the moment was totally not as romantic when you are two shy virgins who have no idea what you're doing.) The reason its so cliché is because I wanted a banner like Jackie and Kelso from That 70s Show had and Nathan and Haley from One Tree Hill lost it to “She Will Be Loved”. Who doesn't want to be like their favorite TV characters?
-Sharon, Florida State University of 2016
Awkward because the guy didn't know I was a virgin. I bled all over his bed and blamed it on my period and he believed me. It didn't hurt like I had always heard and it was a lot of fun until we noticed all the blood. We actually ended up dating for a year after that.
-Sara, University of Kansas Class of 2018
I was 16 and he was 17. It was incredibly awkward and hilarious. We were high school sweethearts and decided to lose our virginities to each other at my house when my parents were out of town. We very obviously had no idea what the heck we were doing and every time our tummies smacked together they made a funny noise and I laughed like an idiot. It was the opposite of sexy but was the sweetest way I could imagine losing my virginity. Man, that was some awful sex... but we cared about each other and I am incredibly grateful he was my first sexual partner.
-Audrey, Christopher Newport University Class of 2017
I didn't want to lose my v-card to a man who would leave me eventually, so my best friend and I got naked in his dorm room, put on a Hot Chelle Rae CD and tried it out. It was awful! It was a mess and we kept on laughing in the middle of it on. Finally we gave up and went out for pizza. I think I'm going to marry that man.
-Cole, Savannah College of Art & Design Class of 2017
During it he asked if I was okay and I said yeah. It was a feeling I cannot explain but I was totally okay with giving him my virginity, I wouldn't of had it any other way. I didn't think of anything but him and how much he meant to me. It didn't last too long, as we both were virgins.
-Catherine, Indiana University of Pennsylvania Class of 2018